Film Analysis #1: Boy Erased (*Spoiler Alert*)

by - September 24, 2019

Image result for boy erased

Film Analysis #1: Boy Erased

Boy Erased is about a Pastor’s son, Jared, who realizes that he is not attracted to the opposite sex. He then participates in a church-oriented program called the Refuge Program. The film goes back and forth from time of the program to when Jared has significant interactions with either men or women. We begin to see how he first realized he was gay. His first physical encounter with man was when he was raped by his college friend. He’s pressured to not say anything to anyone which would obviously change who he is as a person. That same person then tries to sabotage Jared's family by calling his parents and lying about what had happened. After his family realized that it was a lie, his dad tries to set up Jared again with his ex-girlfriend. Jared admits that he’s had thoughts about same-sex relationships and his parents call for help from a pastor and a church friend who’s, as the mom says, “dealt with this before”. His dad then asks Jared, “are you willing to change?”. When Jared says yes, everyone in the room, his parents, the pastor and the church friend, rejoices and prays.

Refuge Program (for LGBTQ) is led by a Mr. Sykes. He composes all these rules that the participants must follow, including no contact and not allowing any discussion of the program to their families. The program is a Christian program designed for the participants to see that LBTQ is a “sin”.

The people in the film are mostly middle class. The program consists of 90% men and 10% women. The men and women are hosted in the same class in the program. The scene of My. Sykes drawing on a white board is a major sin in regards to the topic of Gender, Sex and Class. Mr. Sykes, the Director of the program drew a Venn diagram on a white board and split up the categories and listed things to support that category in his own way. Sykes insisted both categories were choices and produce consequences. Sykes was intentional in making sure that those who were choosing to love or pick to be same sex or gender is acting in sin.

Diagram:
Heterosexual - marriage, family, support, acceptance
Gay/SSA - rape/abuse, promiscuity, aids, loneliness, sinful

At the Refuge Program, Mr. Sykes exploits the parents and forbids the participants to tell their parents. Inside the program, Mr. Sykes has everyone stand up one by one, tell their story, confess their sin and repent.

Everyone who works for the program has a very sadistic view of homosexuals. While Jared goes to the bathroom, a counselor comes in to watch him and calls him a faggot.

Later, in the program, he meets a guy named Xavier. Jared asks him about God and sees his response. At this point in the movie, Jared is trying to figure out who God is and compares himself to Job. Jared tells him that he believes in God and tells Jared that he can show him that God won't "strike down on him." 

Jared also makes another friend who preaches "fake it till you make it." Eventually, every participant there understands that in order to officially "pass" the program, you have to just fake that you're "healed".

While completing the program, Jared and his mom stays at a local hotel where they grow closer together. His mom slowly realizes that this program is not the best program for him. The other boys however have a different experience. One of the participants "acted" on his homosexuality and the next day, his family beats him with the Bible saying "Get out, demon" in front of everyone in the program.

Throughout the movie, we see Jared's story and emotions unravel, but we also see several other characters in the program process their thoughts and their experiences. 

The resolution of this movie was one of my favorite parts: when his parents begin to love him and accept him and realize that they had hurt him.

My response:

Rating: 6/10
I won't give away the ending but as I summarize the significant scenes above, we can see that gender was represented throughout the whole film. The concepts of gender and homosexuality were encountered as issues in the film and was addressed by claiming that "it was a sin" and that "God hates homosexuals." With most of the characters, the issues were never really resolved by the end of the film. Jared's mom's issue with Jared was resolved... and I would like to think that his dad's was resolved, but in a different way.

I admire how Jared's mom fought and loved Jared throughout the whole movie. My favorite part was towards the end, Jared's mom says "I love God, God loves me. It's that simple."

I recommend this movie because of its storytelling. Although, watching the movie made me quite sad. But I don't recommend this movie if you're wanting to validate your beliefs and perceptions of homosexuality. However, this movie does highlight the trauma and pain that a Christian LGBTQ goes through by his/her own family and church. 

Overall, if you're a Christian wanting to challenge yourself in your personal beliefs and perceptions of LGBTQ, this movie might be next on your watch list.

You May Also Like

5 comments

  1. Wow. Heaven will be an interesting place, where we get to see the records of all our deeds, and understand better His final judgement of what is good and what is evil.I'm sure Jared's parents and so many others mean well, even as they struggle to reconcile what God says with what would Jesus do.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I completely agree! At the end of the day, I think I would say that I'd like to live my life letting God have the job of being God and my responsibilities is to love God and love people.

      Delete
  2. This is a matter that will touch us all if not already, and being Christian will not be a shield. In fact it may be harder to deal with for Christians based on existing views. We all need wisdom to love each other and be respectful even if we can't accept alternate lifestyles and persuasions. Thanks Cheya.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hi. I chose the same movie. (great minds think alike) I agree that the story was told well. Looking at the point you made about the mother, I was disappointed by the polarization in the home. I noted that all had difficult decisions to make. On both how to feel and what to say. Those against, may argue that he was a son that only a mother could love. This of course would not be true. All in all one of the main take aways was that all were doing what they thought to be right. I agree with your recommendation to not watch it if you are wanting to validate LGBTQ views or positions, primarily because of the biased perspective the movie was made from.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Hi Cheya, what a story! I can see how hard it was for everyone in the story some because it hit their pride and reputation and others because there is a sense of failure in regards of what they believe and teach. But at the end of the day we all have something to respond to God for, judging is not the answer and we can be sure that God will not ask us to "cast the first stone". The matter will always narrows down to whether we treat our brothers and sisters as it was Jesus. In that view we could say that no matter what we should love, accept, respect and let God deal with the rest.

    ReplyDelete